American Presidents' Attitudes towards Jerusalem (2 / 2)
In our previous article, we explored how
U.S. presidents approached Jerusalem, starting with President Johnson, and
continuing through to President Bill Clinton.
In
this article, we take a look at the positions of the remaining U.S. presidents,
from George W. Bush all the way to Joe Biden.
Eighth: President George W. Bush (2001–2009):
The
Bush administration helped entrench the principle of “security in exchange for
settlement.” Following the events of September 11, 2001, the use of terms like security
and terrorism escalated in U.S. foreign policy, reflecting the global
trend at the time. In the aftermath of the Second Intifada, Bush dispatched the
Director of the CIA to the occupied territories to broker security agreements
between the Palestinian side and the occupation authorities.
As
part of the continuing trajectory of U.S. policy biased toward the occupation,
on September 30, 2002, President Bush signed into law a bill passed by Congress
recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of the occupation. At the time, sources in
the U.S. State Department indicated that implementation of the decision was
left to the White House. The legislation included three provisions related to
Jerusalem, namely:
1. Linking
the funding of its consulate in Jerusalem to the supervision of the U.S.
ambassador to “Israel.”
2. All
official documents issued by the U.S. government shall designate Jerusalem as
the capital of Israel
3. U.S.
citizens born in occupied Jerusalem shall be permitted to have ‘Israel’
recorded as their place of birth
During
Bush’s time in the White House, settlement projects escalated both in Jerusalem and across other
Palestinian areas. It was under his presidency that the construction of the
separation wall began, alongside the continued expansion of settlements and the
establishment of new settlement outposts. Regarding the issue of settlements,
the Bush administration sought to bargain with the Palestinians, pressing them to choose between a freeze on
settlement activity and halting what both the U.S. and “Israel” labeled as
“violence.”
Ninth: President Barack Obama (2009–2017):
Obama
launched his Democratic Party candidacy with statements that underscored his
commitment to supporting the occupation. In a speech delivered at the annual
meeting of the Jewish lobby group AIPAC, he declared his support for “Israel’s”
security and his determination to ensure its continued military superiority,
stating that those who “threaten its security threaten the security of the
United States.” He also affirmed that “Jerusalem will remain the capital of
‘Israel’ and must remain united.
With
his arrival at the White House, the occupied city saw no positive developments.
The arms of the occupation continued Judaizing the city and targeting its Arab
and Islamic landmarks. Settlement activity showed no meaningful decline, while
U.S. policy persisted with nothing more than formal statements of condemnation.
In
the final year of Obama’s presidency came a belated condemnation of settlement
activity. On December 23, 2016, the United States abstained from voting on
Resolution 2334, which called for an end to settlement activities in the
occupied Palestinian territories. By refraining from using its veto power,
Washington allowed the resolution to pass in the UN Security Council.
On
December 28, 2016, then–U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry stressed that
settlement construction was destroying “the hopes of peace for both sides.” In
his final press conference, President Obama warned that “moving the U.S.
embassy to Jerusalem could have explosive consequences.
Tenth: President Donald Trump (2017–2021):
Trump’s term witnessed the most significant shift in favor
of the occupation. His presidency was marked by decisions that bolstered the
occupation and laid the groundwork for a new phase in U.S. dealings with the
occupied city, within the framework of what became known as the “Deal of the
Century.” On December 6, 2017, President Trump announced his recognition of
Jerusalem as the capital of the occupation, along with the transfer of the U.S.
embassy from Tel Aviv to occupied Jerusalem, instructing the State Department
to begin the relocation process.
On
May 14, 2018, the U.S. embassy building was officially relocated from Tel Aviv
to occupied Jerusalem. During the opening ceremony, Trump, in a recorded
message, affirmed that Jerusalem is the true capital of “Israel.”
Then–U.S.
Deputy Secretary of State John Sullivan stated that recognizing Jerusalem as
the capital of the occupation and relocating the embassy there was a step
toward bringing peace to Jerusalem, the region, and the entire world, as well
as an acknowledgment of a reality that had existed for years.
One
of the key files the Trump administration sought to close was that of UNRWA,
through gradually cutting U.S. contributions to the agency. On January 5, 2018,
the United States froze around $125 million of its contribution to UNRWA’s
budget—funds that represented the first installment of the U.S. share for 2018.
Officials in the Trump administration revealed that this freeze was part of
American sanctions on the Palestinians for their refusal to engage in the
so-called “Deal of the Century.
On
January 16, 2018, a U.S. State Department official announced the freezing of
$65 million allocated to UNRWA, funds the agency was originally scheduled to
receive in January 2018.
Under
Trump, the targeting of Jerusalem reached the level of withholding financial
aid previously provided to hospitals in the occupied city. On September 7,
2018, the U.S. State Department announced the suspension of $25 million that
had been earmarked for Palestinian hospitals in occupied Jerusalem.
In
Trump’s final year at the White House, on January 28, 2020, he unveiled the
terms of the so-called “Deal of the Century.” In a press conference held at the
White House alongside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, he pledged that
Jerusalem would remain the undivided capital of “Israel.”
Trump
concluded his term by sponsoring Arab normalization agreements with the
occupation. The “Abraham Accords” included a clear reference to the blessed
Al-Aqsa Mosque, stipulating that Muslims would be granted freedom of access and
worship at Al-Aqsa, while followers of other religions would be granted freedom
of worship in their respective holy sites.
Naturally,
this clause was meant to serve the Jewish settlers. By it, the parties signing
the agreement—including the United States—equated the Muslims’ inherent right
to pray and worship throughout Al-Aqsa Mosque with a fabricated right for Jews
to perform their prayers and rituals within the mosque.
Eleventh: President Joe Biden (2021–2025):
During
Biden’s presidency, his stance on Jerusalem witnessed several developments. The
first was his decision not to reverse Trump’s move of relocating the U.S.
embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, despite his earlier criticism of the
decision. During his election campaign, Biden affirmed that he would keep the
embassy in Jerusalem. At the same time, he promised to reopen the U.S.
consulate in East Jerusalem—closed by Trump—which had provided services to
Palestinians. However, this promise remained unfulfilled through the end of his
term.
Since
the launch of the “Al-Aqsa Flood” operation, U.S. statements in support of the
occupation have not ceased. The Biden administration has reinforced this stance
through unlimited backing of the occupation state—whether by supplying weapons
and air-defense systems, granting billions of dollars to fund the genocide
against Palestinians, or through political positions that provide the
occupation with cover in international forums. It has also justified the
horrific crimes and massacres committed by the occupation forces as acts of
“self-defense,” while echoing the falsehoods promoted by the occupiers.
Conclusion
Trump’s decisions regarding Jerusalem did not alter the
general international stance, which continued to treat the city as occupied
territory. However, the increasing U.S. support since the occupation, coupled
with the absence of any effective Arab or Islamic opposition, encouraged further
backing and a shift toward the occupation. This environment enabled a president
like Trump to take the actions he did, followed by Biden’s massive support for
the massacres in Gaza and Lebanon.
An
objective reading of U.S. presidents’ positions confirms that no American
president has taken serious steps to halt the occupation’s expansion. At times,
U.S. foreign policy has acknowledged that Jerusalem is occupied territory, yet
simultaneously obstructed the passage of resolutions that might constrain the
occupiers. This has allowed the occupation to continue advancing its plans to
seize Palestinian lands.
So,
will we witness further expansion of this aggression under the current Trump
administration, with Palestine and the region teetering on a boiling point?
You Can Also Read:
· Trump and Netanyahu's March Toward Chaos in the Region
· Zionism in the United States (1/10)