Selective Justice in Modern India: Suppressing Opposition and Unleashing Hatred!

By Dr. Mohammad Saud Al-Azmi January 08, 2025 647

 

 

 

In any genuine democracy, the opposition is a fundamental pillar that allows citizens to hold power accountable, review policies, and demand justice. India has long been renowned, as the world's largest democracy, for its diversity of ideas and the freedom of peaceful protest. However, in recent years, a troubling phenomenon has emerged; peaceful dissenters are being imprisoned using strict laws, while those accused or convicted of serious crimes or hate speech remain free without any serious accountability. This paradox reflects a serious imbalance in the Indian judicial system.

Double standards

This situation highlights a reality of double standards, where we find activists and academics such as Umar Khalid, Gulfsha Fatima, Sharjeel Imam, and Irfan Maharaj, who have spent years in prison without a fair trial. In contrast, figures like Ram Rahim, Yati Narsinghanand, Pragyah Thakur, and Kuldeep Singh enjoy notable leniency despite being accused or convicted of heinous crimes.

This stark disparity raises profound questions about the credibility of justice and the rule of law, pointing to a disturbing shift that may undermine the foundations of democracy that India prides itself on.

Imprisonment of Activists and Peaceful Dissenters

In recent years, numerous cases have emerged showing the systemic targeting of peaceful dissenters, with Umar Khalid at the forefront. The former student leader at Jawaharlal Nehru University was arrested in September 2020 under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), with his only "crime" being participation in peaceful protests against policies deemed unjust to minorities. More than 1,550 days have passed, and no fair trial has been held to date.

Similarly, activist Gulfsha Fatima, residing in Delhi, has faced similar circumstances since April 2020. Her detention without substantive progress in legal proceedings illustrates the authorities' insistence on using legal tools to suppress free voices.

In the case of Sharjeel Imam, a prominent researcher at Jawaharlal Nehru University, he was arrested merely for a speech he delivered during protests. These examples clearly reveal how the UAPA has become a repressive tool targeting peaceful dissenters. Not far from this, we see the case of Kashmiri journalist Irfan, who faces vague charges merely for exposing uncomfortable truths.

The UAPA was initially formulated to combat terrorism but has become a sword hanging over the necks of activists, academics, and journalists, leaving them languishing in jails without trial for extended periods.

Leniency Towards Inciters and Those Convicted of Serious Crimes

On the other side of the spectrum, we observe clear leniency towards individuals convicted or accused of serious crimes, and even incitement to hatred. Ram Rahim, leader of the Dera Sacha Sauda sect, was convicted of heinous crimes including murder and rape; nonetheless, he received temporary release on conditional pardon. This blatant leniency raises questions about the state's commitment to enforcing justice.

Yati Narsinghanand

On another front, we find Yati Narsinghanand, a Hindu priest known for his incendiary speeches against Muslims, continuing his public incitement without any serious accountability, despite numerous legal challenges against him. He remains at large, reinforcing the sense of double standards.

As for Pragyah Thakur, a politician in the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the main suspect in the 2008 Malegaon blast case, she was granted bail in 2017 and even succeeded in the 2019 parliamentary elections. This political victory clearly reveals the exploitation of political influence to evade justice.

Finally, Kuldeep Sengar, the former BJP MP who was convicted of raping a girl and murdering her father, was sentenced to life imprisonment. However, he was granted conditional medical release, highlighting a flaw in the enforcement of penalties against influential figures.

Double Standards in the Indian Judicial System

These examples reveal a recurring pattern of selective justice; strict laws like the UAPA are clearly applied selectively against minorities, activists, and political opponents, while perpetrators of violence and hate speech receive unjustified leniency. Political affiliation, religious identity, and sectarianism play a crucial role in determining the course of justice. This duality undermines the judicial system's credibility and negatively impacts society as a whole. Silencing dissent and suppressing activists fosters a culture of fear, while unleashing hatred exacerbates societal divisions.

The Role of Opposition in Democracy

Opposition is not a crime; rather, it is the lifeblood of any democracy. History is filled with peaceful resistance that has led to societal progress and political reform. From the Indian independence movement to modern movements demanding justice, peaceful struggle has played a pivotal role in achieving positive change. It has always relied on free voices to correct course and achieve justice, from the independence movement led by Mahatma Gandhi to contemporary protests. The suppression of dissenting voices not only violates constitutional rights but also weakens the foundation of democracy in the country. Imprisoning students, journalists, and activists sends a clear message: criticism and opposition will not be tolerated, even at the expense of democratic values.

Restoring Justice and Accountability

The path to true democracy begins with reforming the judicial system and ensuring its independence and integrity. There must be:

- Accelerated trial procedures; activists and journalists should not be left languishing in prisons for years without trial.

- Prevention of the abuse of stringent laws; there should be a reassessment of how laws like the UAPA are applied to ensure they are not used as repressive tools.

- Accountability for hate crime perpetrators, regardless of their political or social affiliations; anyone who incites violence or commits serious crimes must be brought to justice.

Strength of India lies in its diversity

The strength of India lies in its diversity and multitude of voices. Maintaining opposition and protecting freedom of expression are the only guarantees for upholding democratic values. Silencing opposition and stifling free voices may serve short-term agendas, but it comes at the cost of justice, equality, and humanity.

In summary, India must recognize that protecting freedom of opinion and accountability is the responsibility of everyone. These values form the cornerstone of a just democracy that embodies the true spirit of India: a nation that embraces all, appreciates their diversity, and ensures justice and equality for all its citizens without discrimination.

Last modified on Wednesday, 08 January 2025 12:59
?> hacklink al hack forum organik hit kayseri escort erotik film izlemarsbahisdeneme bonusu veren siteleropenbook market idMostbet+18 filmcasinolevantdeneme bonusu veren sitelergecelikpijama takımıbetbababetivosultanbet girişbtcbahiscasinomegabetbaba girişdeneme bonusu veren sitelercasino siteleriultrabetGrandpashabetselçuksportsonline casinolilibet norgelilibet norgeindia online bettingbest online casino indiaMikiカジノ 評判Mikiカジノオンカジ 入金不要ボーナスligobet girişkedicasino levantcasinolevantcasinolevantDeneme Bonusu Veren Siteler 2025Grandpashabetcrypto casinobitcoin casinosbest online casino canadasports betting ontariocanadian online casinocrypto casinosGrandpashabetbetnanobetting sitesonline bettingonline casinonew online casinoPornolk21free fire panelsweet bonanzadeneme bonusu veren sitelercasibom 899casibom 899lunabetRoku Bet güncel girişcasibom girişcasibom girişbetlike girişjojobet girişjustin tvdizipalgrandpashabetGrandpashabetayvalık zeytinyağıdoedajojobetbets10snaptwittercasibomtaraftarium24justin tvselçuksportsbetparkbahis siteleritoy poodlejojobetbetturkeyholiganbetbethandhdfilmcehennemiextrabetSekabetbetpark girişbahisseninkolaybet girişmatbet güncel girişbetpark girişdumanbet girişbettiltbettiltcanlı casino siteleriAtlasbet Girişmarsbahisgate of olympus oynaBetgaranti GirişAtlasbetfree instagram followersinstagram takipçi hilesiBetturkeymarsbahisdeneme bonusu veren sitelermarsbahisdeneme bonusu, bedava deneme bonusu veren sitelernorabahiscasinomhub girişbetpark yeni girişcasibom güncel girişcasibomcasibom girişİstanbul Escortmavibetimajbet girişpadişahbetprimebahisBetkanyonsportazabettiltprimebahismatbetmatbetbetbigo girişcasibomaydin escortmanisa escortvaycasinobetebetdeneme bonusuradissonbetatlasbetcasibomcasibom girişbahiscasinoporno izleboşşsahabetprime bahisradissonbetcasibomkaçak maç izlecanlı maç izlegüvenilir casino sitelerien güvenilir casino siteleriolabahis girişbasari betprimebahisterea sigaraelektronik sigarabetturkeyotobetcasibomcasibom girişbetitbet girişparibahis girişbahis sitelericasibomSakarya escortSakarya escortprimebahisiptvjojobet girişjojobetSekabettwidroppercasibombetriyalkingroyalcasibom girişcasibom girişcasibomDeneme Bonusu Veren Siteler 2025casino siteleribahis siteleriprostadine on amazon​free porn deneme bonusu veren sitelerfixbethacklink satın algrandpashabet2222 comcasibom899fixbetgrandpashabet먹튀위크holiganbethiltonbetsekabet güncelcasinolevant girişebetXeno ExecutorRoblox Fisch Scriptceltabetjojobet girişcasinomhub güncel girişhd film izleSnaptikvevobahisjojobet girişjojobetmodabetdinimi porn virin sex sitiliri안전한 카지노사이트 추천 2025바카라사이트 먹튀검증 추천 사이트 2025casibombetleybetdeyneytmey boynuystu veyreyn siyteyleyrBetnanoLuna ExecutorEvon Executorjojobet güncel girişimajbet girişsaveinstacasibom girişcasibomcasibom girişkralbetblox fruits scriptmobilbahisromabetmegabahisbetnano1winbetofficejojobetcasibomholiganbetatlasbet girişSekabet girişdiziwatchcasibom girişcasibomonwincasibomjojobetonwinparibahis girişcasibom girişcasinolevantcrypto casinocasinolevant girişpadişahbetpadişahbetStake GirişStake TrStake Türkiyetruvabetbettilt giriş günceltophillbet girişjojobetslotjackataşehir escortBağcılar escortSekabetGenç sikişcanlı maç izledeneme bonusuprimebahisprimebahis1wincasibomcasibomgüvenilir bahis sitelerijojobetExtrabetesenyurt escortesenyurt escortMariobet Girişcasibomcasibom güncel giriştipobetjojobetsweet bonanza girişBetparkEskişehir escortcasibom girişjojobetholiganbetmatadorbetmatadorbetholiganbetjojobetmarsbahisimajbetizmir escortgobahis twitterbetpublic twitterbetpublic twitterdengebet twitterbetwoon twitterhilarionbet twitterbetbey twitterjoybet twittergobahisbetpublicbetpublicdengebetbetwoonhilarionbetbetbeyjoybetcasibom girişcasibom günceldinamobet twitterkolaybet twittersafirbet twitterbetabet twitterextrabet twittergalabet twitterbetmatik twitterholiganbet twitterdinamobetkolaybetsafirbetbetabetextrabetgalabetbetmatikholiganbetjojobet girişcasibom güncel girişganobetcasibomjojobet girişimajbetmatbetsekabetsahabetonwinmarsbahisjojobetholiganbetcasibomgrandpashabetmatadorbetmatadorbetmatadorbetrestbetbetciobetturkeybetturkey girişbetturkey twitterbetparkimajbetmatbetonwinpadişahbetsekabetsahabetizmir escortCasibomvbetjojobetcasibomcasibom girişEscort izmircasibom girişcasibomcasibomcasibom güncel girişCasibommatbet güncel girişotobetultrabetbettiltbettilt girişjojobetjojobet girişjojobet güncel girişbetplaybetkanyonbahisalbetkolikdiyarbetmaldives casinoCasibom Güncel Giriş adresi: casibom 899 oldukumar sitelerizbahiszbahis girişzbahis twittergooglegooglenbetebetjojobetdumanbetdeneme bonusu veren sitelerExtrabetnakitbahisBetgarantijokerbetmilanobetlimanbetbetturkeywww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygifttimebetpadiahbet girişpalacebetmetrobahishipercasinobetkanyoncasibomcasibom girişhacklink satın aldeneme bonusu veren siteler