How to Teach Children to Say No
In every home and every classroom, an old question keeps resurfacing in a new form: When should we set boundaries, and when should we let a child make their own decisions? How do we raise a child who knows when to say “no”? Should we insist on a parenting style based on listening and obedience because it preserves family unity and authority, or should we teach children to make choices and let them bear the consequences?
The issue is no longer limited to tidying a room or choosing a
toy. Today’s children have access to the world through their screens before
they even understand what a decision, a danger, or responsibility means—or when
they should say, “No.”
When Does Obedience Come from Fear Rather Than Conviction?
Dr. Gamal Ferwiz, Professor of Psychiatry at Cairo University,
identifies several signs of a child who obeys orders simply because they fear
punishment. Such a child is afraid of making mistakes, even minor or
unintentional ones. They hesitate to act without first waiting for instructions
from adults and always agree with their parents, even when they hold a
different opinion.
In his interview with Al-Mujtama, Ferwiz adds that this
child may lie or hide mistakes out of fear of punishment, feel excessive guilt
when going against their parents’ wishes, and hesitate over even the simplest
decisions until they consult someone else. They may appear to be the perfect
child in front of their parents, only to behave in an entirely different way
when they are absent.
He explains that there is a significant difference between a
well-mannered child who respects rules because they understand and accept them,
and a child who has lost the ability to express themselves out of fear of
adults’ reactions.
This approach comes at a cost that becomes apparent later. A
child who grows up believing that others always know better than they do
develops weaker self-confidence. A child who fears mistakes and criticism will
avoid trying anything new, weakening their initiative. They may continue
waiting for their father or mother to solve their problems, even when they are
capable of handling them independently. They also fail to learn responsibility
because they have never had to face the consequences of their own choices.
Anxiety and hesitation may follow them as well.
The situation may even reverse during adolescence, when a
child who has been excessively submissive becomes extremely defiant upon
beginning to demand independence. Dr. Ferwiz calls this phenomenon “delayed
rebellion.”
Children’s Choices and the Parenting Mistakes That Undermine Them
Dr. Ferwiz identifies several parental mistakes that can lead
to this outcome. These include controlling every choice a child makes, from their
clothes and friends to their hobbies and the way they play. Another mistake is
punishing children for their mistakes instead of helping them learn from them.
A child who is punished for every mistake learns to avoid trying, not how to
succeed.
Other serious mistakes include mocking children’s choices with
remarks such as, “You don’t understand,” or “You’re too young.” Contradictory
expectations are equally damaging: asking children to become independent and
then rejecting every decision they make, or demanding honesty and then
punishing them when they confess.
One of the most common parental mistakes is constantly
comparing a child to others. As a result, the child remains preoccupied with
seeking people’s approval instead of developing a healthy sense of self-worth.
The Numbers Reveal What Is Happening in Children’s Bedrooms
Children no longer remain at home waiting for permission to
explore the world. In Saudi Arabia, the 2025 Report on Household and Individual
Access to and Use of Information and Communications Technology revealed
widespread family concern about children’s internet use. Some 63.7% of
households use parental control tools, compared with 29.6% that do not, while
35% say they would like to use them.
In Egypt, the Central Agency for Public Mobilization and
Statistics reported in August 2026, citing Growing Up Online, a report
by Kaspersky, a cybersecurity company, that 29% of Egyptian children had
received contact attempts from adults they did not know. It also found that 30%
of their accounts were publicly accessible, while 77% played games unsuitable
for their ages. Meanwhile, 41% had accidentally encountered violent content,
and 23% had viewed it intentionally.
These figures tell us something important: children are not
waiting for anyone’s permission. When nearly three out of every ten children
receive a message from a stranger, they find themselves alone with three
possible responses: reply, ignore it, or tell their parents.
In the United Arab Emirates, the Cabinet approved a decision
in June 2026 prohibiting children under the age of 15 from creating or
operating personal accounts on social media platforms. Those aged 15 and 16 are
permitted to use them provided that protective measures are in place. These
include age-based content restrictions, disabling high-risk features,
regulating screen time, and providing parental control tools.
However, prohibition alone is not enough, as Australia’s
experience demonstrates. Australia was the first country in the world to introduce
a law, effective December 10, 2025, prohibiting children under 16 from holding
accounts on social media platforms.
Nevertheless, in late July 2026, the eSafety Commissioner
announced that more than eight out of every ten Australians under 16 had continued
using social media three months after the ban. This was because companies had
failed to implement effective age-verification measures. In June 2026, Amnesty
International described the ban on teenagers as “the right diagnosis and the
wrong prescription.”
The Quranic Approach: Obedience and Consultation
Obedience in Islam does not mean blind submission, just as independence does not
mean freedom from responsibility. Islamic teachings illustrate this through
three principles:
First: Consulting children and involving them in
decisions. In the story of Abraham and his son Ishmael, peace be upon
them—the greatest example of filial devotion and obedience—the father did not
simply surprise his son with the command. Instead, he presented the situation
to him and asked for his opinion: {˹Abraham˺ said, “O my dear son! I have seen in a dream that I ˹must˺
sacrifice you. So tell me what you think.”}
[As-Saffat 37:102]. His son responded with understanding and submission: {He
replied, “O my dear father! Do as
you are commanded. Allah willing, you will find me patient.”} [As-Saffat
37:102].
Second: Respecting a child’s opinion. A
tumbler (full of milk or water) was brought to the Prophet (peace be upon him)
who drank from it, while on his right side there was sitting a boy who was the
youngest of those who were present and on his left side there were old men. The
Prophet (peace be upon him) asked, “O boy, will you allow me to give it (i.e.
the rest of the drink) to the old men?” The Prophet sought the child’s
permission, giving him the right to respond.
Third: Responsibility remains essential. The
Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said: “So each of you is a shepherd
and each of you is responsible for his flock.” (Narrated by Al-Bukhari and
Muslim). Parents cannot abandon this responsibility under the pretext of
respecting their children’s independence.
The Prophetic model, therefore, is built on care, presence,
and guidance, alongside teaching children understanding and responsibility.
How to Build Independence Without Sacrificing Security
Dr. Gamal Ferwiz advises parents to give children
opportunities to make decisions appropriate to their age. For example, they can
choose between two types of clothing or food. Their responsibilities should
then increase gradually to include managing their time, organizing their
belongings, completing school assignments, and participating in some family
decisions. Children must also learn that every choice has consequences.
During adolescence, between the ages of 12 and 18, parents
should gradually move away from issuing commands and toward dialogue,
negotiation, and shared responsibility. Teenagers need privacy and respect for
their opinions, while clear boundaries must remain in place when it comes to
safety, health, values, and responsibilities. One major mistake is treating a
teenager as though they were still five years old.
It is also extremely important to explain the reasons behind
rules. A child who does not understand why they should not add a stranger
online, or why a particular action is prohibited, will not necessarily follow
the rule when nobody is watching. Parents should also allow their children to
say “no” when making their own choices, so they can learn to say it to
strangers in dangerous situations. They should create an environment where
children can admit their mistakes without being punished, because a child who
fears punishment will hide the truth.
Absolute obedience cannot protect a child in an open world,
and absolute freedom cannot build a responsible human being. The choice between
obedience and independent decision-making is misguided from the outset. The
safer path is a form of parenting that is both firm and warm: one that explains
before giving orders, supervises without harshness, and teaches children how to
make decisions before the moment comes when they must make one.