Male Guardianship in Islamic Feminism Discourse
Husband’s guardianship over the wife is considered one of the central
concepts in Islamic thought. The foundation of this guardianship is found in
the words of Allah the Almighty: {Women have rights
similar to those of men equitably, although men have a degree ˹of responsibility˺ above them. And Allah is Almighty,
All-Wise.} [Al-Baqarah 2:228]
And His
saying, {Men are the caretakers of women, as men
have been provisioned by Allah over women and tasked with supporting them
financially.} [An-Nisa’ 4:34]
These two
verses indicate the leadership of the man over the woman. As Ibn Kathir
explained in his interpretation of the latter verse: “He is her leader, her
chief, her authority, and the one responsible for disciplining her if she
deviates.”
This is
supported by what was narrated from the Prophet (peace be upon him): “When a woman
observes the five times of prayer, preserves her chastity, and obeys
her husband, she will be told to enter by any of the gates of paradise she
wishes.” (Narrated by Ahmad)
The Meaning of Guardianship (Qiwamah) in
Islamic Marriage
The Noble
Quran explains the rationale behind this guardianship through the qualities
that Allah has granted men—physical and psychological traits that suit their
leadership roles—as well as the financial responsibility that Islam places upon
them toward their wives and children.
Therefore,
qiwamah is not a form of domination or oppression, but rather a responsibility
and duty of care for the welfare of the family. It is conditioned by justice
and kindness and does not justify injustice or abuse.
Allah
says, {Treat them fairly.} [An-Nisa’ 4:19] And
the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “The best of you
is he who is best to his family, and I am the best among you to my family.”
(Narrated by At-Tirmidhi)
Guardianship may also
fall from the husband if he neglects financial support or fails to fulfill his
responsibilities. Likewise, it does not mean the erasure of a woman’s
personality or her legal capacity, but rather organizes marital life by
appointing a leader who ensures family stability and prevents its
disintegration.
Contemporary Interpretations of Qiwamah
The
concept of qiwamah has received significant attention from classical scholars
and later from contemporary scholars who have revisited the concept in light of
changing social and cultural conditions.
These
scholars emphasize that qiwamah does not mean authoritarian control, but rather
is based on consultation, dialogue, and mutual understanding within the
framework of mercy, affection, and tranquility that the Quran intended for marriage.
They also
stress that Islamic Shari`ah allows space for interpretations that correspond
with the realities of the age, provided that such interpretations remain within
the legitimate principles of sound scholarly reasoning.
However,
some modernist currents have convinced themselves that the Quranic text emerged
within a specific historical context and that qiwamah does not represent an
essential superiority of men. Instead, they claim it resulted from particular
economic and social conditions that existed at the time of revelation, and
therefore its meaning may change once women regain their social status.
Modernist
trends that call for redefining qiwamah often subject religious texts to
interpretive methods that do not respect the nature of sacred scripture, aiming
instead to align them with liberal values.
Among the
most controversial of these trends is what is known as “Islamic feminism.”
This movement cloaks itself in Islamic terminology while presenting
reinterpretations that reshape religious texts to support its ideological
views.
Its
proponents claim that the texts of the Quran and Sunnah established male
dominance and granted men authority to oppress women, depriving them of their
rights and dignity while questioning their intellectual and managerial
abilities.
Feminist Approaches to Reinterpreting
Islamic Texts
In order
to reject male guardianship—which they consider the primary cause of gender
inequality—feminist writers have attempted to reinterpret religious texts and
assign them new meanings.
Through
this process, they depart from the original objectives of revelation. Their
interpretations are often selective, highlighting what supports their vision of
equality while ignoring other texts that do not fit that perspective.
As a
result, their approach dismisses the traditional scholarly tools used in
Islamic jurisprudence that protect religious interpretation from distortion.
Some of
these writings even include statements such as: “Religion and the state in the
Muslim world have turned women into sexual servants of their husbands”, or
claims that “many religious rulings are merely male-biased human
interpretations rather than binding divine commands.”
Muslim
feminist thinkers have sought to reread Islamic texts through a critical and
liberationist lens, accusing earlier interpretations of superficiality. In
their efforts to deny gender distinctions,
they affirm that the Quran establishes equality between men and women in
humanity and dignity.
Some rely
on literary interpretive methods to derive or construct meanings from a
feminist perspective, often bypassing the literal wording of the Quran and its
textual context.
Criticism of Hadith and Islamic
Jurisprudence in Feminist Discourse
Prophetic
hadith has also been subject to significant criticism in feminist discourse.
Some writers describe hadith as a politically influenced product and therefore
reject it entirely, relying solely on the Quran.
Others
question the authenticity of major collections of Sunnah and claim that they
were influenced by Jewish and Christian traditions. When some feminists accept
certain hadiths, they often select those that support gender equality while
disregarding others.
Likewise,
classical Islamic jurisprudence is often described by feminist writers as
incompatible with modern realities. According to their claims, it emerged from
a patriarchal cultural environment. Consequently, some portray Muslim jurists
as the true enemies of women, accusing them of intentionally depriving women of
their rights.
Feminist Interpretations of the Verse of
Qiwamah
There
have been multiple feminist interpretations of the Quranic verse: {Men are the caretakers of women.} [An-Nisa’ 4:34]
All of
these interpretations attempt to redefine the word in a way that supports
complete gender equality without limitations and rejects the traditional
juristic understanding altogether.
Feminist
writers argue that classical commentators placed excessive authoritarian
meanings on the verse and that their interpretations were influenced by the
patriarchal cultures of their time, where men held social authority.
Based on
this argument, they claim that Quranic rulings related to women are historical
rulings tied to the period of revelation and therefore open to change—even if
they belong to the category of clear and established texts.
Others go
further by arguing that qiwamah in the verse is not limited to the husband-wife
relationship but represents a broader form of mutual responsibility. They
support their claim with the verse: {Women have
rights similar to those of men equitably.} [Al-Baqarah 2:228]
According
to them, this verse eliminates male guardianship and instead establishes
complete justice and equality.
Consequently,
they reinterpret qiwamah as a conditional functional responsibility: a man may
have authority only as long as he fulfills the roles of financial provider and
protector. If these conditions disappear, then his leadership also disappears.
The Social Consequences of Redefining
Qiwamah
The
feminist discourse surrounding qiwamah has produced significant consequences
for Muslim societies and has opened the door to debates that many scholars
consider harmful. Among these consequences are:
Weakening
the authority of sacred texts in public consciousness: By promoting interpretations that diverge sharply from
traditional scholarship, people may lose a stable reference point for religious
understanding, leading to a decline in religious certainty.
Fueling
social division: By creating polarization
between opposing intellectual camps, this discourse weakens the cultural unity
of society and influences family dynamics, such as encouraging wives to reject
the authority that Islamic law grants to husbands.
Loss of
civilizational identity: By adopting Western interpretive frameworks, these reinterpretations can produce confusion
regarding religious and cultural identity within Muslim societies.
For Further Reading:
- The Contradiction Between Feminism and Common Sense
- Opium of Islamic Feminism shaking the Foundations of Muslim Homes
- Book Review: “The Secret of a Successful Family Life” By Sheikh Wahiduddin Khan
-------------------------------------------------------------