Why Nations Fail? - by: Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson

Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson's Why Nations Fail? is not merely an academic treatise; it is a profound and engaging exploration into one of humanity's most pressing questions: why do some nations prosper while others remain trapped in a cycle of poverty and instability? After more than 15 years of research and study across continents, Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson present arguments that can contribute to changing many concepts, shaking the certainty of some deeply entrenched traditional beliefs, and even proving them to be misleading.

Faulty Traditional Theories

The authors meticulously debunk what they call "faulty traditional theories." Acemoglu and Robinson systematically dismantle many simplistic explanations for the success or failure of nations, such as geography, culture, and leadership competence. They provide compelling examples to support their views.

For instance, the divided Koreas—North Korea and South Korea—share one people and similar geography, yet their economic realities are entirely different. The second example is Japan's dramatic post-war transformation, which defies cultural determinism.

Flawed Arguments

The authors assert that blaming a nation's plight on its climate or the intelligence of a single leader is not merely an oversimplification, but often a justification for colonial narratives that exert immense efforts to keep those nations incapacitated, ensuring they remain raw material reservoirs and markets for the world's dominant powers. Indeed, colonialism created elites who dominate media and education in these nations, tirelessly repeating these flawed arguments.

Inclusive Versus Extractive Institutions

The authors' arguments revolve around the concept of inclusive versus extractive institutions. They emphasize that for any nation to succeed, it must possess effective inclusive political institutions that widely distribute power, encompass every corner of the nation and all its components, excluding no one. These institutions must ensure the application of the rule of law to all (especially leaders themselves) and foster free elections and a transparent, independent media.

The authors stress the necessity of creating inclusive economic institutions that protect property rights, encourage innovation, provide public services, and allow broad participation in the economy. This means preventing the concentration of wealth and opportunities in the hands of a few exploitative climbers, who are often ignorant or foolish. The book clearly demonstrates how prosperity is fundamentally linked to the quality of the institutions governing the state, intrinsically tied to the state of the economy and prosperity.

It further explains that what it calls extractive institutions—whether political (such as one-party rule or military dictatorships) or economic (such as monopolies)—lead to national failure. Such systems, which concentrate power and wealth in the hands of a small, ignorant, foolish elite—who are the ruler's confidantes and entourage, not people of knowledge and expertise—stifle innovation, discourage hard work, and ultimately lead to economic stagnation and collapse, even if temporarily supported by abundant natural resources, as seen in examples like Venezuela.

Drivers of Change and Transformation

One of the most thought-provoking aspects of the book is its discussion of how nations change. Acemoglu and Robinson highlight critical junctures that nations may experience (such as wars or revolutions), which can drive gradual transformations towards the establishment of inclusive institutions. However, the authors acknowledge a formidable challenge, even if nations experience violent upheavals like wars and revolutions: the powerful influence of the "feedback loop between power and wealth," which keeps many nations ossified and resistant to change.

In conclusion, Why Nations Fail? presents a strong, evidence-based argument that shifts the focus, when analyzing the causes of national failure, from superficial factors to the fundamental institutional structures that shape a nation's destiny. Therefore, the book is valuable in its subject matter for researchers, scholars, economists, and anyone interested in public affairs seeking to understand the root causes of global disparities. The book provides a compelling framework for analyzing the issue of prosperity and failure in the past and present. The book is also rich in information, owing to its academic rigor and extensive studies, yet its central thesis is clear and simple, making it an excellent contribution to political economy. The book not only provides an elaborate explanation but also empowers readers to think critically about the phenomena surrounding them.

-----------------