When Do Empires Fall?
The
closer an empire comes to its collapse, the more erratic its laws become(1) —
and erratic here does not merely mean irrational, but rather the dominance of
delusion: the empire begins to see everything around it as fragile entities
that can easily be erased from existence. At that point, the empire embarks on
its downward trajectory. This is perhaps what American biologist of Russian
origin Peter Turchin addressed in his book Ages of Discord: A
Structural-Demographic Analysis of American History — great empires do not
die by being killed; they die by suicide.
The
American-Iranian conflict raises many profound questions, among them whether
any empire or major power — such as the United States — can achieve its
objectives through force and impose its will on all others. It also raises the
question of whether possessing power necessarily means the ability to execute
goals, secure victory, and subjugate others.
Since the
dissolution of the Soviet Union on December 26, 1991, the United States
transformed into the dominant pole on the stage of world politics, as the
international order shifted from a bipolar system to a unipolar one.
The
dangerous phase of that new world order was marked by the emergence of what
became known as the "Rumsfeld Doctrine" — a military strategy adopted
by Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld (who served from 2001 to 2006), built
on reliance on limited yet rapidly deployable ground forces, backed by advanced
technology and overwhelming air power. The objective was for the United States
to possess the capacity to wage war on two fronts simultaneously and emerge
victorious on both.
This
doctrine was applied in Afghanistan and Iraq, where American forces succeeded
in occupying and devastating both countries — yet they did not prevail. After
years of engagement, the United States withdrew with enormous political and
economic losses, having failed to achieve its stated objectives.
The Fall: Romans and Americans
Some five
centuries ago, the renowned French philosopher Montesquieu sought to analyze
the causes behind the rise and fall of the Roman Empire, publishing his work Considerations
on the Causes of the Greatness of the Romans and their Decline in 1734. He
attributed Rome's ascent — which spanned nearly three centuries — to the deeply
rooted values of liberty and the flexibility of its political and military
institutions.
In their
wars and much of their policy, the Romans would readily adopt the methods of
their enemies when those methods proved superior. Montesquieu observed: what
made the Romans masters of the world was that they fought the peoples of the
earth one by one, and after each encounter, whenever they found the enemy's
methods more effective than their own, they immediately abandoned theirs and
embraced those of their adversary. If one were to reflect on that brilliant
observation and compare it to the Rumsfeld Doctrine — built on the strategy of
winning on two fronts simultaneously — the scale of American power's erosion
becomes clear. The United States is now waging conflict on multiple fronts at
once, fighting against Chinese and Russian influence at the very heart and
depth of the Asian continent through its confrontation with Iran.
Between the Centrality of War and Economy
Montesquieu
affirms in his book that the Romans were neither merchants nor industrialists,
but rather fierce warriors — war was the source of their wealth. Establishing a
just system for distributing the spoils of war was among the pillars of their
strength; plunder was used as a tool to reinforce belonging and identity, and
its equitable distribution played a central role in sustaining and entrenching
the institution of war.
Looking
at the American case, while the United States may be the greatest military
power in human history, it is the economy that forms the central pillar of that
empire — and the lifeblood of that economy is energy, secured through control
over its sources by various means of dominance.
The
energy conflict occupies perhaps the most prominent and consequential place in
American strategy within the current confrontation. Washington seeks to control
Gulf oil energy sources in order to constrain Chinese economic and political
growth, which has begun to escape containment efforts — a reality that China
fully understands, seeing itself as the true strategic target of current
American policy and military posture.
Iran, for
its part, understands that the threat to deny everyone access to energy — both
in production and maritime transit through the Strait of Hormuz — is a pressure
card against the American empire far greater than it is a card against Tehran
itself. The centrality of the economy, and the centrality of oil within
American power, have become strategically threatened, leaving the American
empire with little choice but to yield.
History
tells us that the British Empire's economy was built on raw materials extracted
from the peoples it occupied, and when the flow of those resources ceased, the
empire on which the sun never set finally went dark. By the same logic, should
oil supplies to the American economy diminish or dry up, a similar decline
would likely strike that empire as well.
In a
study published by Time magazine in December 2018, titled "The Fall
of Rome and the Lessons for America," the piece argued that the greatest
danger facing long-established republics like the United States is not a sudden
assault by an ambitious tyrant, but rather the gradual erosion of their
cultural and institutional foundations.
The study
further argued that the story of the ancient Romans offers a harsh lesson for
contemporary Americans: the strong defenses that protect old republics erode
gradually if not regularly reinforced, and this deterioration often begins with
a phenomenon such as deepening wealth inequality. Yet no republic is eternal —
it endures only as long as its citizens wish it to.
American
thinker Paul Kennedy, in his book The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers,
argues that all empires ultimately lose their cohesion under the effects of
time — that erosive forces wear them down as the years accumulate. Empires come
and go with time, and no empire endures forever.
In his
book, Kennedy studied international and regional powers from the year 1500,
focusing on the relationship between economics and strategy as a governing law
that dictates the rise and fall of empires. Power and wealth, he argues, are
inseparable at the core of any empire: wealth is a weapon that sustains
military power, and military power is an instrument that enables the
acquisition and protection of wealth.
We find
ourselves confronted with a truth Kennedy raised in his book — one that may
allow us to anticipate the future of the American empire in the decades ahead.
That truth is the danger of imperial overstretch: the spread of an empire's
military forces across vast stretches of the world, whether through occupation,
military bases, or large-scale wars that carry enormous economic, human, and
political costs. This becomes an existential threat to the empire when the
weight of staggering expenditure outpaces the strategic, economic, and
political returns. At that point, the empire begins its descent into relative
economic decline — a collapse that does not arrive suddenly, but unfolds along
an extended trajectory, proportional to the immense costs the empire has borne
without securing returns sufficient to offset them.
The Erosion of Prestige
The
erosion of prestige is a telling indicator of imperial decline. History
instructs us that a portion of an empire's power rests not solely on its
material strength, but on its prestige — what political scientists call
deterrence. When a great power fails to convince its adversaries that the cost
of confronting it outweighs the benefits of submission, the very architecture
of its dominance begins to crumble.
The
erosion of prestige frequently drives an empire to resort to the use of force —
drawing it into confrontations with smaller powers that drain its military and
economic strength. The power of prestige and deterrence lies precisely in the
ability to project force without actually deploying it; when deterrence fails,
the resort to force becomes inevitable.
The
unspoken dimension of prestige erosion is the waning of the empire's
overwhelming power, alongside the qualitative improvement in the capabilities
of rivals — their growing ability to confront, endure, challenge, and drain
imperial strength. This emboldens many powers to think seriously and
practically about resisting the great power's dominance. Strategically, the
external erosion and retreat of prestige is a symptom of the empire's weakening
and its inability to sustain the costs of hegemony.
No Empire Lasts Forever
Empires
most often find their end through war, yet in times of peace they unravel,
fragment, and dissolve — and with the passage of time, collapse and fading
become inevitable. The Ottoman Empire, for instance, was afflicted by weakness
for centuries until Russian Tsar Nicholas I described it as "the sick man
of Europe" in 1853, yet its final collapse did not come until nearly
seventy years later.
The
causes underlying imperial collapse are manifold. French historian
Jean-Baptiste Duroselle wrote a book titled Every Empire Will Fall, in
which he argued that empires born of the will to power and conquest inherently
rely on rule by force, the coercion of peoples, enslavement, and even terror.
The inevitable fate of these structures, born of excess, is collapse. He
distilled this into a maxim: every empire is destined to perish.
You may
also like:
4 Islamic Empires That Led the World
5 Motives for the Outbreak of Wars in the World
Footnotes:
1. A
Quote from Cicero, Orator of Ancient Rome