Qur’anic Method of Argumentation
In light of the spread
of the culture of debates, arguments, and discussions—which have become
dominant in our contemporary reality to the point where some people dedicate
most of their time to them—it is imperative for Muslims to draw inspiration
from the Qur'anic method of debate. They must define its purpose, distinguish
between what is permissible and what is forbidden, recognize the
characteristics of Qur'anic argumentation, and recall its examples.
Permissible
and Impermissible Argumentation
Argumentation is
frequently condemned in the Qur'an. Among the ayahs that mention it negatively
are: “No one disputes concerning the signs of Allah
except those who disbelieve.” (Ghafir: 4) and “And
they disputed by [using] falsehood to [attempt to] invalidate thereby the truth.”
(Ghafir: 5) However, Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to engage
in it in a specific manner. He said, “Invite to the
way of your Lord with wisdom and good instruction, and argue with them in a way
that is best.” (An-Nahl: 125) He also permitted it for the group of
believers, saying, “And do not argue with the
People of the Scripture except in a way that is best, except for those who
commit injustice among them.” (Al-Ankabut: 46) From this, it is
understood that the permissible form of argumentation is that which is
conducted in a good manner, unlike the other forms that are condemned and
prohibited.
Argumentation
(Jidal) and Proof-Based Debate (Hujjah)
By default,
argumentation is forbidden due to the way it stirs each party to strive for
dominance and superiority. It is even more prohibited among believers. The
predecessors of the Ummah, across all levels, strongly condemned argumentation.
It was narrated from Ibn ‘Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both): “Do
not argue with your brother, for argumentation does not bring out wisdom and is
not safe from its harm.”
(Jami‘ al-Usul by Ibn al-Athir 2/753) They considered abandoning it
to be part of the essence of true faith. Ibn ‘Umar (may Allah be pleased with
them both) said: “A man does not attain the reality of faith until he abandons
argumentation, even if he is right.” (Narrated by ‘Abdullah ibn Ahmad in Az-Zuhd,
2134)
They also considered it
a sin. Abu Ad-Darda’ (may Allah be pleased with him) said: “It is enough sin
for you to be constantly argumentative.”
(Narrated by Ad-Darimi 293 in detail, and Ibn Abi Ad-Dunya in As-Samt,
130) They mentioned its harmful effects on both individuals and the community.
Malik ibn Anas (may Allah have mercy on him) said: “Argumentation in
knowledge hardens the hearts and breeds grudges.” (Narrated by Ibn ‘Asakir
in Tarikh Dimashq, 61/205) There are many other statements to this
effect which may be reviewed in reliable books of creed.
The exception is what
is done in a good manner and serves the intended purpose of argumentation: the
emergence of truth. There is no better method than the Qur'anic approach to
achieving this, which is why it must be carefully examined.
The Art of Debate in the Qur'an
Characteristics
and Methods of Qur'anic Debate
Qur'anic method of debate
contains such unique features and methods that even volumes would not suffice
to fully discuss and analyze them. What follows is only a portion and does not
replace comprehensive study.
1. Calling
upon the motivators of truth: knowledge, remembrance, reason, and reflection
This is a valid
foundational principle that leads to the intended outcome of argumentation.
Those who follow falsehood rarely rely on it. Most of their arguments are based
on imitation, habit, and denial without knowledge. Allah said regarding their
state: “Rather, they say like what the former
peoples said. They said, 'When we have died and become dust and bones, are we
indeed to be resurrected? We have been promised this, we and our forefathers,
before; this is not but legends of the former peoples.'” (Al-Mu’minun: 81-83) Yet
Allah called them to abandon that path by clinging to knowledge and
remembrance: “Say, [O Muhammad], 'To whom belongs the earth
and whoever is in it, if you should know?' They will say, 'To Allah.' Say,
'Then will you not remember?'” (Al-Mu’minun: 84-85) He called for reasoning in many parts of the Book,
including: “O my people, I do not ask you for it
any reward. My reward is only from the one who created me. Then will you not
reason?” (Hud: 51) And He called for reflection in many parts of the
Book, including: “Say, 'Is the blind equivalent to
the seeing? Then will you not give thought?'” (Al-An‘am: 50)
2. Beginning
from what should be a shared premise
The flaw of any
unproductive dialogue is the absence of a shared foundation between the two
parties, from which agreement can be pursued. This is a key objective of
argumentation, and it is established in Allah’s saying:
“Say, 'O People of the Scripture, come to a word that is equitable between us
and you - that we will not worship except Allah and not associate anything with
Him and not take one another as lords instead of Allah.' But if they turn away,
then say, 'Bear witness that we are Muslims [submitting to Him].'” (Aal ‘Imran:
64)
3. Addressing
both intellect and emotion
Human beings have
multiple entry points. Some are persuaded by rational arguments, while others
respond more to emotional appeal. At times, both may be needed—or one more than
the other depending on the situation. The Qur'anic method perfects this
balance, addressing both intellect and emotion. Take, for example, the
following ayahs: “And they say, 'The Most Merciful
has taken [for Himself] a son.' You have done an atrocious thing. The heavens
almost rupture therefrom and the earth splits open and the mountains collapse
in devastation that they attribute to the Most Merciful a son. And it is not
appropriate for the Most Merciful that He should take a son.” (Maryam: 88–92)
4.
Establishing truth by eliminating false possibilities
Reason itself finds
certain possibilities to be impossible, leaving only the valid option. In the
Qur'an’s debate for the existence of the Creator, it enumerates false
alternatives until only the true one remains. Allah says, “Or were they created by nothing, or were they the
creators [of themselves]? Or did they create the heavens and the earth? Rather,
they are not certain. Or do they have the depositories [containing the
provision] of your Lord? Or are they the controllers [of them]?” (At-Tur:
35–37)
5. Clarity
and precision
A distinguishing
feature of the Qur’anic arguments is that they are clear and precise. They do
not rely on obscurity or aim to convince only the highly intelligent while
leaving out those of average understanding. Rather, they achieve the highest
level of clarity while remaining accessible.
Take, for example, the
Qur’anic argument for the obligation of worship based on the fact of creation: “O mankind, worship your Lord, who created you and those
before you, that you may become righteous.” (Al-Baqarah: 21) Likewise,
the story of Prophet Ibrahim’s debate with Nimrod and his silencing of him with
a conclusive and clear argument: “[Abraham] said,
'Indeed, Allah brings up the sun from the east, so bring it up from the west.'
So the disbeliever was overwhelmed [by astonishment], and Allah does not guide
the wrongdoing people.” (Al-Baqarah: 258) And similarly, in proving that
the Qur’an is the word of Allah: “And We certainly
know that they say, 'It is only a human being who teaches the Prophet.' The
tongue of the one they refer to is foreign, and this Qur'an is [in] a clear
Arabic language.” (An-Nahl: 103)
6. Refuting false
claims by proving the truth of their opposites
This is a natural and
rational principle, for two opposites cannot coexist nor both be nullified. If
one of them is false, the other must be true. The Qur’an has invalidated the
claims of its opponents through this method. Allah says, “And they did not appraise Allah with true appraisal when
they said, 'Allah did not reveal to a human being anything.' Say, 'Who revealed
the Scripture that Moses brought as light and guidance to the people? You
[Jews] make it into pages, disclosing [some of] it and concealing much. And you
were taught that which you knew not—neither you nor your fathers.' Say, 'Allah
[revealed it].' Then leave them in their [empty] discourse, amusing themselves.”
(Al-An’am: 91)
How beautiful and clear
this path is, how easy its course is for the one who seeks benefit and the one
who imparts it, and how powerful its impact is upon every living heart. To the
One who clarified the proof and made the path manifest—praise be to Him for His
blessings. And Allah, Exalted and Blessed, has spoken the truth when He said: “It is not but a message and a clear Qur’an. To warn
whoever is alive and justify the word against the disbelievers.” (Ya-Sin: 69–70)
How the Qur’an Reaches the Depths of the Human Soul!
-------------------------------------------------------------